This post will be utilized to reflect on the investigative work of another fellow JUS 633 classmate.
RP: Your piece is very thought provoking and distinct in its subject matter to me for three reasons: 1) This is the first time I’ve read or head of anyone extensively studying and explaining the history of self defense in non-violence movements and reasons supporting why the concept should be applied in these demonstrations of social activism. 2) You are actively engaged in this ‘debate’ as a participant in the Occupy_________ Movement in addition to the fact that 3) the movement is extremely recent in American social history. What a great position you have for writing about this topic, to give first hand experience as well as a critical analysis on what is taking place now. You’re essentially penning history as it occurs and potentially may serve as a pundit on the issue years from now; fascinating! I also want to commend you on advocating to those who engage in non-violent movements the adoption of all principles associated with such action, not a buffet-style approach to protesting (i.e. picking and choosing which concepts to apply). If you’re going to do something, you might as well do it full-heartedly, right?
I have a few questions for you with regard to your paper:
1) On page 10, you reference how during the Civil Rights era much of the publicity shown pertaining to the unjust treatment of participants in the movement at the hands of police and other municipal representatives (i.e. firemen with their fire hoses, sheriffs, etc.) was focused on those who were minorities in comparison to their non-black, non-hispanic, etc. counterparts. As a flipping of this scenario, do you think since the Occupy ________ Movements taking place around the country tend to be supported more by persons who are not of color is the reason why these demonstrations are receiving so much media attention? If the movements were more centralized racially society wouldn’t pay much attention because minority groups historically have struggled economically (it’s not a new concept, for example)?
2) You briefly describe your positioning in the community of which you are studying, how being a white male in this movement has privileged you in some ways (education, class positioning, etc.) as well as detracted from your credibility as being able to relate to those who campaign for this cause. What are your approaches for overcoming this? It would be nice to read a bit more on this in your paper.
Great job and best wishes! -BPR